
The Myth of Becoming a Local Abroad: What Belonging Really Means for Expats
Wondering if you can truly become a local when moving abroad? Here’s why that goal might not be as helpful as you think—and what to focus on instead to feel at home in your new country.
“I Want to Become a Local” – But What Does That Really Mean?
If I had a euro for every time a client told me they wanted to become a local, I’d probably be sipping espresso on a balcony somewhere.
It’s a common wish: to fit in, blend with the culture, speak the language, adopt the customs, and just feel like you belong. I get it. That desire is very human. But here’s the thing I often say—sometimes out loud, sometimes only in my head:
You can’t truly become what you’re not.
Sure, you can integrate beautifully, speak fluently, and respect the local way of life. But you won’t become a local. And honestly? That’s not a bad thing.
What People Actually Mean When They Say This
When I dig a little deeper and ask, “What does becoming a local mean to you?” the answer is almost always about belonging.
People want to feel accepted. They don’t want to stand out. Some feel like locals get more respect, while foreigners are often seen as outsiders. So what they’re really craving is to feel “normal” in their new environment.
That’s completely valid—but trying to achieve it by becoming someone you’re not? That’s a recipe for frustration.
Belonging Has Nothing to Do with Language or Habits
The truth is, belonging isn’t about how well you follow local customs. It goes deeper than that. Belonging comes from a connection—often unspoken—with the people around you. And that connection usually grows out of shared values, not shared habits.
This is where things can get tricky. You might discover that the things you care about deeply just aren’t as important in your new country. That realization can shake your idea of what living abroad would feel like. Sometimes it’s just a crack. Other times, the whole illusion shatters.
Let’s Talk Expectations
Here’s something I remind my clients often: we all have expectations when we move abroad. Even the people who swear they don’t.
(“I have no expectations!”... Yep. That’s an expectation.)
And let’s be real—reality rarely lives up to what we imagined. That doesn’t mean it’s worse. Just different. Your version of “becoming a local” might not look anything like how that actually plays out in real life.
So… What Is a Local, Anyway?
Before we chase this elusive identity, it’s worth asking: What does being a local really mean?
Here’s where it gets interesting. Our brains love shortcuts. There’s even a name for it—out-group homogeneity bias—which basically means we tend to lump everyone who isn’t “us” into one big category.
So when we say things like “All Italians are like this,” or “Everyone in Portugal does that,” it’s that mental shortcut talking. In reality, locals aren’t one big homogenous group. They’re just as varied and complex as any other group of people—including expats.
A Better Way: Create Your Own Culture
Now, here’s where things get more empowering.
Instead of trying to become a local, I encourage you to create your own culture.
I call it cherry picking—and I’ve been doing it for years, long before I had a name for it. When I was working on my master’s in intercultural psychology, I finally found the words to describe what I’d been doing all along.
I take the habits, values, and customs I love from each country I’ve lived in—and I leave the rest. I create a lifestyle that feels right to me. One that reflects who I am and what I care about, no matter where I’m living.
And guess what? That’s where the real sense of belonging comes from. Not from fitting in, but from living in alignment with your values.
You Don’t Have to Fit In to Belong
If you’ve been struggling to feel like you belong, or wondering why it all feels harder than you expected—you’re not alone. So many people try to fit in so hard, they end up losing parts of themselves. And when it doesn’t work, they start to question everything.
“Maybe this country isn’t for me.”
“Maybe I made a mistake.”
“Maybe I’ll never feel at home.”
But what if the real issue isn’t the country—it’s the expectation?
Want Some Help Finding Your Own Way?
If this resonated with you, I have a free resource that can help:
Download my free ebook: Move Overseas with Ease
In it, I dive deeper into strategies for adjusting to a new country in a way that’s authentic and empowering—on your terms.